skills: a gate that could pass without checking, and a mailbox that never empties

Fixes the three blockers and seven should-fixes from pi@emb-7kj4vr4g's review
(logstream correlation skills-provenance-review, full text in
drawer_pi-devbox_reviews_e43e766641c9ec85217bc6ce). Every finding was
reproduced by execution here before being fixed; two were refined by that
reproduction rather than taken as given.

BLOCKER 1 — the provenance gate could print OK and exit 0 without verifying.
`git show <ref>:<path> | sha256sum` hashes EMPTY STDIN when the ref does not
resolve, so at_ref was never empty and the UNKNOWN branch was dead code.
Measured: a bogus ref reported MISMATCH — accusing the snapshot of lying when
the real cause was an incomplete clone, and the operator's natural remedy for
MISMATCH is to re-run the refresh, which rewrites provenance to silence the
complaint; and with a 0-byte snapshot against a 0-byte upstream file it printed
"OK: exactly skillset@aaaaaaa" with exit 0 for a ref that does not exist. The
script already had the sha_empty idiom and had applied it to blob_sha but not
to at_ref. Existence is now PROVEN with git cat-file -e before anything is
hashed, at two levels (ref resolves / path exists at it) because those deserve
different messages. Same defect class as the canary it replaces: a check that
can succeed without checking. A second, unflagged instance of the same pipeline
shape in blob_sha was found and fixed too.

Exit codes split, because the old contract failed the sanctioned case: 0
truthful (including stale, with a NOTICE), 1 a lying record only, 2 cannot
determine. AGENTS.md step 2 promised "the message distinguishes the two" and
was the thing this branch was breaking; rewritten to state all three.

BLOCKER 3 — VENDORED.md contradicted itself in the release whose stated
invariant is non-contradiction: its hand-maintained provenance line named
skillset 670f7f1, seven commits behind the ARG and itself the commit that told
agents to hand-stamp added_by — the withdrawn instruction this work exists to
stop shipping — while its cp recipe contradicted the "not cp" rule 20 lines
above. Line removed (nothing forced it to move when the ARGs did); 670f7f1 kept
only as a labelled cautionary example. The pi-extensions half was verified
redundant (CI require_sha resolves PI_EXTENSIONS_REF) before removal.

SHOULD-FIXES: `<root> --check`, the spelling VENDORED.md documented, silently
ran a REFRESH because only $1 was parsed (both tools now parse all args and
reject unknown ones); refresh at a detached/older HEAD silently rewound ref and
bytes (now refused unless the recorded ref is an ancestor, --force to override);
upstream_dirty was computed and never used in check mode; --no-skills --json
printed human text and broke jq; --help was a hardcoded sed range this branch
had already made stale; the fingerprint hashed SKILL.md alone so a live skill
differing only in a sibling file reported "identical", and pi-extensions already
ships two files, so it is now a per-skill TREE hash with the manifest field
renamed skillset_snapshot_tree_sha256; the --no-skills smoke assertion was
negative-only and passed on a crashed binary. mktemp+mv left files 0600 — CI was
unaffected since the index records 100644, so the blast radius was local builds
only, narrower than the review inferred.

Snapshot resynced c04cd15 -> 5fd0d5c so the no-clone fallback carries the
CORRECTED coordination protocol rather than the withdrawn one; --check is now OK
with no staleness notice, and the bidirectional canary re-verified against the
new bytes. Local validation is bash -n only (shellcheck, hadolint and actionlint
are all absent in this container) — CI remains the shellcheck gate.

AGENTS.md

@@ -66,18 +66,32 @@ re-brand of opencode-devbox's `pi-only` variant.
    the upstream changelog to include in `CHANGELOG.md`.
 2. **Refresh the vendored mempalace skill snapshot if the skillset moved:**
    `scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh --check` (reads a real skillset clone,
-   writes nothing). Exit 1 means either the recorded `SKILLSET_SNAPSHOT_REF`
+   writes nothing). Three exit codes, not two — a stale-but-truthful record is
-   does not describe the shipped bytes, or upstream has moved past it — the
+   **not** a release blocker, so don't treat any non-zero exit as "must
-   message distinguishes the two. Refresh with
+   refresh" without reading which one it was:
-   `scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh`, which rewrites the file **and** the ARG
+     - **0** — the record is truthful. This includes stale-but-truthful
-   together so they cannot drift apart.
+       (upstream has moved past the recorded ref, or the local clone has
-   Two consequences to accept deliberately: the snapshot is hashed into
+       uncommitted changes) — a `NOTICE` is printed, but nothing is lying.
-   `base_tag`, so refreshing costs a base rebuild (~67 min); and if the section
+       **Skipping the refresh in this case is the legitimate, sanctioned
-   the phrase canary names has changed, re-pin it in `scripts/smoke-test.sh`.
+       outcome** — every enrolled host reads its own live skillset clone, so
-   **Skipping this is legitimate** — every enrolled host reads its own live
+       the baked copy is only a no-mount fallback. What is not legitimate is
-   skillset clone, so the baked copy is a no-mount fallback. What is *not*
+       skipping it *silently*: the drift is visible here, in
-   legitimate is skipping it silently: the drift is visible in
+       `pi-devbox-version`, and in the manifest, so decide rather than forget.
-   `pi-devbox-version` and in the manifest, so decide rather than forget.
+     - **1** — a confirmed problem: the vendored bytes provably do NOT match
+       the file at the recorded ref (a lying record), or the recorded ref
+       doesn't even resolve to that path in this clone. Refresh.
+     - **2** — cannot determine (the recorded ref itself isn't resolvable in
+       this clone — commonly a shallow checkout missing history). Fetch full
+       history and re-check before deciding; don't refresh blind.
+   Refresh with `scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh`, which rewrites the file
+   **and** the ARG together so they cannot drift apart, and refuses (exit 1)
+   rather than silently rewinding provenance if the skillset clone's HEAD is
+   behind the already-recorded ref (detached HEAD, older checkout) — pass
+   `--force` only if that rewind is genuinely intended.
+   Two consequences to accept deliberately on an actual refresh: the snapshot
+   is hashed into `base_tag`, so it costs a base rebuild (~67 min); and if the
+   section the phrase canary names has changed, re-pin it in
+   `scripts/smoke-test.sh`.
 3. Update `CHANGELOG.md` Unreleased → vX.Y.Z section.
 4. Verify `docker compose up` works locally with the current `latest` image
    if you're upgrading users from a previous version. Then run the

CHANGELOG.md

@@ -16,6 +16,81 @@ Pre-v1.0.0 tags followed the pi npm version (`v{pi_version}[letter]`).
 The vendored `mempalace` skill snapshot stops being anonymous, and the
 container starts saying which copy of each skill it is actually reading.
 
+**Peer review (pi@emb-7kj4vr4g, logstream correlation
+`skills-provenance-review`, full text in
+`drawer_pi-devbox_reviews_e43e766641c9ec85217bc6ce`) found three blockers before
+this was tagged. All three were the same species: a record asserting something
+it had not verified. Every finding below was reproduced by execution here before
+being fixed.**
+
+- **The verification gate could print `OK` and exit 0 without verifying
+  anything.** `git show <ref>:<path> | sha256sum` hashes *empty stdin* when the
+  ref does not resolve, yielding a real-looking `sha256("")` rather than an
+  empty string — so the `UNKNOWN` branch in `--check` was dead code. Reproduced:
+  a bogus ref reported `MISMATCH` (accusing the snapshot of lying when the true
+  cause was an incomplete clone — and the operator's natural remedy for
+  MISMATCH is to re-run the refresh, which *rewrites provenance to silence the
+  complaint*); with a 0-byte snapshot against a 0-byte upstream file it printed
+  `OK: … exactly skillset@aaaaaaa` and exited 0 for a ref that does not exist.
+  The script already had the right idiom (`sha_empty`) and had applied it to
+  `blob_sha` but not to `at_ref`. Now existence is *proven* with `git cat-file
+  -e` before anything is hashed, at two levels (does the ref resolve; does the
+  path exist at it) because those are different failures. This was the same
+  defect class as the canary it replaces: a check that can succeed without
+  checking. A second, unflagged instance of the identical pipeline shape was
+  found in `blob_sha` and fixed too.
+- **`--check`'s exit codes conflated "stale" with "lying",** so the release step
+  failed in the case `AGENTS.md` step 2 explicitly calls legitimate. Now: `0`
+  truthful (including stale-but-truthful, with a `NOTICE`), `1` a lying record
+  only, `2` cannot determine (ref absent from this clone). `AGENTS.md` step 2
+  rewritten to state all three, since its promise that "the message
+  distinguishes the two" was exactly what the branch was breaking.
+- **`VENDORED.md` contradicted itself, in the release whose stated invariant is
+  non-contradiction.** Its hand-maintained "Snapshot provenance at last refresh"
+  line named skillset `670f7f1` — seven commits behind the ARG, and *the very
+  commit that told agents to hand-stamp `added_by`*, i.e. the withdrawn
+  instruction this line of work exists to stop shipping — while its `cp` recipe
+  still contradicted the "not `cp`" rule 20 lines above. The hand-maintained
+  line is gone (nothing forced it to move when the ARGs did); `670f7f1` is kept
+  only as a labelled cautionary example. The `pi-extensions` half was verified
+  redundant (CI resolves `PI_EXTENSIONS_REF` via `require_sha`) before removal,
+  rather than silently dropped.
+
+**Should-fixes from the same review, all reproduced:** `--check` given the
+documented positional spelling (`<root> --check`) silently ran a *refresh*,
+because only `$1` was parsed — both tools now parse all arguments and reject
+unknown ones; a refresh at a detached or older `HEAD` silently rewound ref and
+bytes, now refused unless the recorded ref is an ancestor (`--force` to
+override); `upstream_dirty` was computed and never used in check mode, now
+reported; `pi-devbox-version --no-skills --json` printed human text and broke
+`jq`; `--help` was a hardcoded `sed -n '2,22p'` range that this branch had
+already made stale; the skill fingerprint hashed `SKILL.md` alone, so a live
+skill dir differing only in a sibling file still reported "identical" — and
+`pi-extensions` already ships two files — so it is now a per-skill **tree** hash
+and the manifest field is renamed `skillset_snapshot_tree_sha256` to say what it
+measures; and the `--no-skills` smoke assertion was negative-only, passing on a
+crashed binary, now anchored positively. `mktemp`+`mv` left written files at
+`0600` (a `mv` takes the temp file's mode) — CI was unaffected because the git
+index records `100644`, but a local build from a dirty tree would have baked it;
+now `chmod 0644` before the `mv`.
+
+**The skill fix ships outside this release, because it had to.** The review also
+found that skillset `82a8d3c` — the coordination protocol itself — told every
+machine on this fleet to *skip* the mailbox it introduced: it gated the mailbox
+on `mempalace_mesh_peers`, and a hub-and-spoke palace reports `peers: []`
+precisely because every machine is a thin client of one replica. It also
+asserted that a directed `open` event "stays in their mailbox until" acked —
+false, because `event_ack` appends and `status` is written once, so an answered
+ask matches forever. The headline measurement behind that claim ("exactly 1 —
+the one that needed a reply") was of an event already acked half an hour
+earlier. Fixed in skillset `5fd0d5c`, which derives owed-ness by joining on
+`ack_of`/`correlation_id` with a **`seq` ordering test** — without which one
+terminal reply suppresses every later ask on the same thread forever. Because
+the skillset is mounted live on every enrolled host, that correction was already
+deployed fleet-wide before this image was built; the vendored snapshot is
+resynced to it (`c04cd15` → `5fd0d5c`) so the no-clone fallback does not ship
+the withdrawn rule. Canary re-verified bidirectionally against the new bytes.
+
 **Also carried, previously undocumented:** `dbb7879` resynced the vendored
 `mempalace` snapshot to skillset `c04cd15` ("the withdrawal only holds where the
 bridge is live"), landed after the v1.8.7 tag and so absent from that image.

Dockerfile.variant

@@ -305,7 +305,7 @@ ARG MEMPALACE_TOOLKIT_REF=main
 # no ~67-minute base rebuild. (scripts/check-base-hash.sh scans only
 # Dockerfile.base, so no folding into the base hash is required — nor would
 # it be correct, since this ARG changes nothing about the base's contents.)
-ARG SKILLSET_SNAPSHOT_REF=c04cd156592decf8258cfce7aa5e123ac0a5c7e2
+ARG SKILLSET_SNAPSHOT_REF=5fd0d5c406df506fd0e70977b6bd87f5fbc3b803
 
 # Dockerfile.base sets description="pi-devbox — base image (variant-independent)"
 # and every variant INHERITS it, so both published images used to advertise
@@ -365,12 +365,26 @@ RUN set -e; \
     # reader with the skillset checked out — which on this fleet is every
     # host, since all four compose stacks mount it — verify the claim at
     # RUNTIME, without CI ever needing access to the private repo. Degrades
-    # to JSON null rather than failing the build if the file is absent; the
+    # to JSON null rather than failing the build if the directory is absent;
-    # smoke assertion is what turns that into a loud failure.
+    # the smoke assertion is what turns that into a loud failure.
+    #
+    # Hashes the whole DIRECTORY, not just SKILL.md: a single-file hash
+    # answers "did this one file change", not "is the live copy the same
+    # skill" — a live checkout that added or edited a SIBLING file (a
+    # reference/ doc, a helper script) would still report "identical to
+    # baked snapshot" against a file-only hash. pi-extensions already ships
+    # two files for exactly this reason (SKILL.md + evaluate-extension-usage.py),
+    # so this is not a hypothetical. Deterministic over `find | sort`, never
+    # readdir order: relative paths + per-file sha256, folded into one hash.
+    # pi-devbox-version mirrors this exact pipeline over the live directory so
+    # the two sides are comparable — if you change this, change that too.
+    tree_sha256() { \
+      ( cd "$1" && find . -type f -print | LC_ALL=C sort | xargs -r sha256sum ) 2>/dev/null | sha256sum | cut -d' ' -f1; \
+    }; \
     SKILL_SNAP='null'; \
-    _snap_file=/usr/local/share/pi-devbox/skills/mempalace/SKILL.md; \
+    _snap_dir=/usr/local/share/pi-devbox/skills/mempalace; \
-    if [ -f "$_snap_file" ]; then \
+    if [ -d "$_snap_dir" ] && [ -n "$(find "$_snap_dir" -type f -print -quit)" ]; then \
-      SKILL_SNAP="\"$(sha256sum "$_snap_file" | cut -d' ' -f1)\""; \
+      SKILL_SNAP="\"$(tree_sha256 "$_snap_dir")\""; \
     fi; \
     { \
       echo '{'; \
@@ -388,8 +402,10 @@ RUN set -e; \
       # lie a future reader would act on), and `pi-devbox-version` renders
       # every components{} value with .value[0:12] — which would truncate
       # a 64-hex sha256 into something that looks like a short commit.
+      # Named `_tree_sha256`, not `_sha256`: it measures every file under the
+      # vendored skill directory, not one file — see tree_sha256() above.
       echo "  \"skillset_snapshot_ref\": \"${SKILLSET_SNAPSHOT_REF}\","; \
-      echo "  \"skillset_snapshot_sha256\": ${SKILL_SNAP},"; \
+      echo "  \"skillset_snapshot_tree_sha256\": ${SKILL_SNAP},"; \
       echo "  \"components\": {"; \
       echo "    \"pi-toolkit\": \"$(rev /opt/pi-toolkit)\","; \
       echo "    \"pi-extensions\": \"$(rev /opt/pi-extensions)\","; \

rootfs/usr/local/bin/pi-devbox-version

@@ -28,15 +28,33 @@ MANIFEST=/etc/pi-devbox/build-manifest.json
 MODE="human"
 SHOW_SKILLS="yes"
 
-case "${1:-}" in
+# A `case "${1:-}"` here only ever looked at the FIRST argument, so
-  --json)  MODE="json" ;;
+# `--no-skills --json` matched --no-skills, silently dropped --json, and
-  --quiet|-q) MODE="quiet" ;;
+# printed human text to a caller expecting JSON (a real failure: a jq
-  --no-skills) SHOW_SKILLS="no" ;;
+# consumer piping that output gets a parse error, not a wrong-but-parseable
-  --help|-h)
+# answer). Loop over every argument instead, and reject anything unknown
-    sed -n '2,22p' "$0" | sed 's/^# \?//'
+# rather than silently ignoring it the same way.
-    exit 0
+for _arg in "$@"; do
-    ;;
+  case "$_arg" in
-esac
+    --json)      MODE="json" ;;
+    --quiet|-q)  MODE="quiet" ;;
+    --no-skills) SHOW_SKILLS="no" ;;
+    --help|-h)
+      # Print the leading `#`-comment block verbatim, stopping at the first
+      # non-comment line, rather than a hardcoded line range: `sed -n
+      # '2,22p'` was silently truncating --help because this file has grown
+      # usage lines since that range was written, and a fixed range will
+      # drift again the next time a comment is added above it.
+      awk 'NR==1{next} /^#/{sub(/^# ?/,""); print; next} {exit}' "$0"
+      exit 0
+      ;;
+    *)
+      echo "pi-devbox-version: unknown option: $_arg" >&2
+      echo "  try --help" >&2
+      exit 2
+      ;;
+  esac
+done
 
 if [ ! -f "$MANIFEST" ]; then
   echo "pi-devbox-version: no build manifest at $MANIFEST" >&2
@@ -132,8 +150,21 @@ if [ "$SHOW_SKILLS" = "yes" ] && [ -d "$BAKED_SKILLS" ] && [ -d "$SKILLS_DIR" ];
   # Recorded provenance of the vendored mempalace snapshot (absent on images
   # built before this existed — `// empty` so a JSON null never prints as the
   # 4-char string "null", the same trap noted for mempalace_version above).
+  # `_tree_sha256`, not `_sha256`: it is a hash over every file in the
+  # vendored skill DIRECTORY (see tree_sha256() below), not one file, because
+  # a single-file hash reports "identical" against a live checkout that added
+  # or edited a sibling file — pi-extensions already ships two files, so this
+  # is not hypothetical.
   snap_ref=$(jq -r '.skillset_snapshot_ref // empty' "$MANIFEST")
-  snap_sha=$(jq -r '.skillset_snapshot_sha256 // empty' "$MANIFEST")
+  snap_sha=$(jq -r '.skillset_snapshot_tree_sha256 // empty' "$MANIFEST")
+  # Same pipeline Dockerfile.variant uses to measure the baked directory at
+  # build time: relative paths in `find | sort` order, each hashed, the whole
+  # listing folded into one sha256. Keep the two definitions identical — they
+  # run in different processes (image build vs. this container) and are
+  # meaningless to compare unless they agree byte-for-byte on the algorithm.
+  tree_sha256() {
+    ( cd "$1" && find . -type f -print | LC_ALL=C sort | xargs -r sha256sum ) 2>/dev/null | sha256sum | cut -d' ' -f1
+  }
 
   # Iterate the baked tree rather than a hardcoded name list, so vendoring a
   # fourth skill needs no edit here. The header prints only if the tree is
@@ -176,9 +207,12 @@ if [ "$SHOW_SKILLS" = "yes" ] && [ -d "$BAKED_SKILLS" ] && [ -d "$SKILLS_DIR" ];
     # For the one skill whose baked fingerprint we recorded, say plainly
     # whether the live copy differs from what shipped. This is the check CI
     # cannot perform (the skillset is private) and the container can, free.
+    # Hash the whole live DIRECTORY with the same tree_sha256() used to
+    # measure the baked one in Dockerfile.variant — a SKILL.md-only compare
+    # would silently ignore a changed or added sibling file.
     _live_sha=""
-    if [ -n "$snap_sha" ] && [ "$_name" = "mempalace" ] && [ -f "$_target/SKILL.md" ]; then
+    if [ -n "$snap_sha" ] && [ "$_name" = "mempalace" ] && [ -d "$_target" ]; then
-      _live_sha=$(sha256sum "$_target/SKILL.md" 2>/dev/null | cut -d' ' -f1 || echo "")
+      _live_sha=$(tree_sha256 "$_target")
     fi
     if [ -z "$_live_sha" ]; then
       printf '    %-22s %s\n' "$_name" "$_where"

rootfs/usr/local/share/pi-devbox/skills/VENDORED.md

@@ -114,15 +114,31 @@ mounted, plus a fabricated-skillset run of the reconciler).
 
     cp <pi-extensions-pkg>/skill/SKILL.md                    pi-extensions/SKILL.md
     cp <pi-extensions-pkg>/skill/evaluate-extension-usage.py pi-extensions/
-    cp <skillset>/skills/mempalace/SKILL.md                  mempalace/SKILL.md
 
-Copy each snapshot **from its owner in the table above** — `pi-extensions` from
+Copy `pi-extensions` **from its owner in the table above** — the package
-the package repo's `skill/` (since `a7f3044` co-located it there; `skillset`
+repo's `skill/` (since `a7f3044` co-located it there; `skillset` also carries a
-also carries a copy, but it is a downstream duplicate and can lag), and
+copy, but it is a downstream duplicate and can lag). Copying `pi-extensions`
-`mempalace` from `skillset`. Copying `pi-extensions` from `skillset` would
+from `skillset` would regress the snapshot to whatever that repo last mirrored.
-regress the snapshot to whatever that repo last mirrored.
 
-Snapshot provenance at last refresh: skillset `670f7f1`, pi-extensions pkg `e73cb9f`.
+`mempalace` is **not** refreshed by `cp` — see the *Freshness model* section
+above: `scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh <skillset-root>` is the only thing
+that should ever touch that snapshot, because a bare copy can update the bytes
+without updating the ref that claims to describe them, which produces a
+manifest that confidently lies.
+
+Neither vendored skill has a hand-maintained "last refreshed at" line here on
+purpose — one previously existed (skillset `670f7f1`, pi-extensions pkg
+`e73cb9f`) and went stale within hours, because nothing forced it to move
+when the ARGs did. `670f7f1` is now a cautionary example rather than a fact
+worth recording: it is the commit that told agents to hand-stamp `added_by`,
+which a later skillset commit (and the pi-devbox edge stamper) withdrew — so a
+reader trusting that line would have been pointed at superseded guidance.
+Both facts it tried to capture now live somewhere that cannot drift by hand:
+
+| Fact | Where |
+|---|---|
+| which skillset commit `mempalace`'s bytes came from | `ARG SKILLSET_SNAPSHOT_REF` (Dockerfile.variant) + `skillset_snapshot_ref` in `build-manifest.json`, written *only* by `vendor-mempalace-skill.sh` |
+| which pi-extensions package commit was vendored | `ARG PI_EXTENSIONS_REF` (Dockerfile.variant, CI-resolved to a 40-hex commit) → OCI label `se.jordbo.pi-devbox.pi-extensions-ref` and `build-manifest.json`'s `components.pi-extensions`, both read from the actual `/opt/pi-extensions` checkout, not from intent |
 
 When you refresh the `mempalace` snapshot, also update the phrase asserted by
 the "mempalace skill snapshot is current" smoke test — it deliberately pins the

rootfs/usr/local/share/pi-devbox/skills/mempalace/SKILL.md

@@ -41,6 +41,21 @@ Run these immediately when a session begins, before responding to the user:
    mempalace_kg_query(entity="<project_or_person>")
    ```
 
+4. **Check your mailbox.** Just run it — an empty result is a fine answer and
+   costs one call. Do not try to decide first whether coordination "applies to
+   you"; that test is what used to be wrong here (see *Cross-Machine
+   Coordination* below):
+   ```
+   mempalace_event_list(to_agent="<harness>@<device>", status="open")
+   ```
+   This is a candidate list, not a to-do list — `status` never changes after an
+   event is written, so finished asks keep matching. Subtract the ones you have
+   already answered using the rule in *What you actually owe*, below.
+   Another machine may have asked you something, or corrected something you are
+   about to rely on. This costs one call and is the only way you will find out:
+   nothing pushes an event into your session unless your bridge delivers it for
+   you, and if it does you will already have seen it before reading this.
+
 Do NOT announce this to the user. Just do it silently to orient yourself.
 
 ### Temporal grounding — compute time deltas, don't guess
@@ -340,6 +355,158 @@ mempalace_kg_invalidate(subject="...", predicate="...", object="...", ended="<to
 mempalace_kg_add(subject="...", predicate="...", object="...", valid_from="<today>")
 ```
 
+## Cross-Machine Coordination — the logstream
+
+The palace stores what you *know*. The logstream (`mempalace_event_*`,
+`mempalace_artifact_*`) carries what you want to *say to another agent* —
+delegation, review, patch handoff, retraction. It is the only channel on which
+another machine can reach you.
+
+**Does this apply to you at all? Do not use `mempalace_mesh_peers` to decide.**
+It answers a different question than it appears to. A shared palace can be
+*hub-and-spoke* — many machines as thin clients of one central replica — and
+then `mesh_peers` reports `peers: []` because there are no peer *replicas*,
+even while four machines are actively writing to the same log. Measured on this
+fleet: `peers: []`, one replica authoring every event from every machine. An
+earlier version of this section told you to read `mesh_peers` and skip the
+mailbox when it came back empty, which disabled the mailbox on precisely the
+fleet it was written for.
+
+The honest discriminators, cheapest first: **just run the mailbox query** (empty
+is a fine answer); check whether `MEMPALACE_REMOTE_URL` is set, which is what
+actually selects a shared palace; or look for any event whose `from_agent` is
+not you. On a solitary palace the event tools still work — you are writing to
+yourself and your mailbox stays empty. That is not a fault to debug.
+
+**It is a durable log, not a bus — nobody is "listening".** Events are appended
+and persist; there is no subscription, no delivery window, and nothing is lost
+by being offline when one is written. A message waits indefinitely for you, and
+your reply waits just as patiently for a sender who has since gone away. Machines
+in a fleet are rarely awake at the same time, which is exactly why this is a log
+and not a chat.
+
+**Agent name is the only identity the log has.** Depending on deployment, every
+client may share one `origin_replica` — on the fleet this skill was written for,
+all machines are thin MCP clients of a single central replica, so `origin_replica`
+is identical for every event and cannot tell two machines apart. `from_agent` /
+`to_agent` carry the whole distinction, which is why the `<harness>@<device>`
+stamping in *Provenance is stamped for you* is load-bearing here and not mere
+tidiness.
+
+### Reading your mailbox
+
+```
+mempalace_event_list(to_agent="<harness>@<device>", status="open")
+```
+
+- `to_agent=<you>` **also matches `*` broadcasts**, so one call covers both. No
+  second query needed.
+- `status="open"` narrows the mailbox to what a sender *said was an ask at the
+  time of writing* — that is all it can do. It is a good first filter (on a real
+  stream it cut 5 events to 2), but it is **not** a list of what you owe, and it
+  never shrinks as you work. Treating it as owed-ness is the mistake this
+  section previously made: an earlier draft cited "5 unfiltered, exactly 1
+  filtered — the one that needed a reply" as proof the filter tracked
+  obligation. It did not. That single result was an event which had *already
+  been acked* half an hour earlier; the filter looked decisive only because the
+  stream happened to contain one directed `open` event. **Unfiltered mailboxes
+  train you to ignore them — and so does a filter that keeps showing you
+  finished work.**
+- To resume where you left off, use `since_event_id`, **never**
+  `since_created_at`. A timestamp cursor permanently skips an event that synced
+  in late — it is a time window ("what happened today"), not a cursor.
+- Read `metadata` before acting: senders put the load-bearing specifics there
+  (which host verified what, which run failed, what a change retracts).
+
+### The ack contract — the sender declares whether a reply is owed
+
+An obligation you never agreed to is noise, so the sender states it:
+
+| Sender writes | Means | Recipient owes |
+|---|---|---|
+| `to_agent="<specific agent>"` + `status="open"` | an ask | an ack or a reply (the event itself keeps matching forever — see below) |
+| `to_agent="*"` (any status) | broadcast FYI | nothing |
+| any other status (`ready`, `applied`, `blocked`, …) | a statement of fact | nothing |
+
+Ack with `mempalace_event_ack(event_id=…, from_agent="<you>", status=…)`. It
+**appends a new event** and never mutates the original; the correlation id is
+copied for you, and `metadata.ack_of` is set to the event you answered.
+
+#### What you actually owe — derive it, do not read it off `status`
+
+The log is append-only and `status` is written **once**, so it is an honest
+statement about an item *at the moment it was written* and nothing more. It is
+not mutable state, and asking it to carry mutable state is what breaks:
+acking appends a new event and changes nothing about the old one, so **a
+directed `open` event matches your mailbox query forever, answered or not.**
+Nothing is ever "dismissed" — which also means a deferred ask cannot be
+accidentally lost, only that you must compute what is outstanding:
+
+```
+candidates = mempalace_event_list(to_agent="<you>", status="open")
+mine       = mempalace_event_list(from_agent="<you>")
+```
+
+A candidate is **answered** when one of your own events
+
+1. has a **higher `seq`** than the candidate, and
+2. joins to it — `metadata.ack_of == candidate.id` (exact, written for you by
+   `event_ack`) or the same `correlation_id` (the fallback), and
+3. carries a **terminal** status: `applied`, `superseded`, `failed`, `blocked`.
+
+Everything else is still owed. Two calls, constant cost.
+
+**Compare `seq`, never `created_at`** — the same reason you resume with
+`since_event_id`. Without the ordering test, one terminal reply would suppress
+every later ask on the same `correlation_id` for good; verified on a live thread
+where a `ready` reply at `seq` 16 sits *before* the request at `seq` 17 that it
+obviously cannot have answered.
+
+This also supplies the "taken, not finished" state that looked missing:
+`claimed` and `ready` are deliberately **not** terminal, so work you have picked
+up keeps resurfacing until you close it out. No extra convention, no new field.
+
+Two consequences worth internalising:
+
+- **"Seen, not doing it" is a legitimate ack** — `status="blocked"` or
+  `"superseded"` plus the reason. Silence is not, and it is not merely rude:
+  with no terminal event of yours to join to, the ask stays in the owed set
+  indefinitely and there is nothing anyone can do about it from the other end.
+- **Nothing expires, and it should not.** An `open` with no terminal reply is
+  still live by definition, and the finished threads are valuable history. If
+  content is genuinely perishable ("do not push to main for the next hour"), say
+  so in `metadata.expires_at` — metadata is stored verbatim — and honour it as a
+  hint when reading. An old `open` that the derivation still counts as owed is a
+  signal, not garbage: it means somebody asked and nobody answered.
+
+### Writing to another machine
+
+- **Address the stamped name you actually saw** in a `from_agent` field, e.g.
+  `pi@tor-ms22`. A bare `pi` reaches nobody's mailbox once stamping is live, and
+  older events in the log still carry bare names — do not copy them.
+- **Use `status="open"` only when you truly need an answer.** It places an
+  obligation on another machine.
+- **Never broadcast an ask.** `to_agent="*"` + `status="open"` obliges everyone
+  and therefore no one.
+- **Always set a `correlation_id` on a directed `open`,** and reply with the
+  same one. It is not just for reconstructing a conversation later: it is the
+  join the owed-set derivation depends on. An uncorrelated ask can only ever be
+  closed by an `event_ack` (which sets `ack_of` for you) — a plain reply cannot
+  be matched to it at all.
+- **Corrections are new events, never edits.** Say explicitly what you retract
+  and name the id — drawer or event — that carried the withdrawn claim.
+- **Put a retraction where the reader will look.** An event reaches a live agent;
+  a *drawer* is what a future semantic search finds. If you filed advice as a
+  drawer and later withdraw it, file the withdrawal as a drawer too — otherwise
+  the next agent finds your original confident advice and no trace of the
+  correction. (This is a real incident, not a hypothetical.)
+- **Hand over exact content as an artifact**, not prose: `mempalace_artifact_put`
+  or `mempalace_patch_submit` store bytes with a sha256, and the event references
+  the id. Never paste a diff into a body and hope it survives.
+- **Waiting on a specific reply?** `mempalace_event_wait` blocks with backoff —
+  do not poll `event_list` in a loop. A timeout there is a normal result, not an
+  error.
+
 ## Palace Structure
 
 ### Wings
@@ -413,4 +580,6 @@ Entity-relationship triples with temporal validity. Query with `mempalace_kg_que
 - **Don't mine .git directories or node_modules.** The CLI miner respects .gitignore by default.
 - **Don't create duplicate drawers.** Use `mempalace_check_duplicate` before adding manually.
 - **Don't treat the palace as a task list.** It's for knowledge and context, not todos.
+- **Don't broadcast an ask, and don't leave one unanswered.** On a shared palace, `to_agent="*"` + `status="open"` obliges every machine and therefore none of them. And don't expect acking to tidy your mailbox: `status` is immutable, so the event keeps matching either way — what a terminal reply buys you is that the *derived* owed set (see *What you actually owe*) stops counting it. Leave asks unanswered and that set only grows, until everyone learns to stop looking. "Seen, not doing it" is a complete answer — silence is not.
+- **Don't assume you would have heard.** Nothing pushes another machine's message into your session. If you did not run the mailbox query at wake-up, a correction addressed to you by name can sit unread while you confidently rebuild the thing it warned you about.
 - **Don't invent provenance metadata, and don't hand-stamp it either.** An earlier version of this list told you to set `added_by="<harness>@<device>"` by hand; that instruction has been withdrawn, because RFC 001 §7.3.2 places provenance at the client/server boundary and the pi bridge now does it uniformly (see *Provenance is stamped for you* above) — but the withdrawal only holds where the bridge is live, so run the one-line check in that bullet first; on an older image hand-stamping is still the only signal a hand-filed drawer gets. DO NOT invent values for the palace's own metadata fields (`device`, `agent_kind`, `origin_device`): those are stamped by infrastructure that also records *how* each was determined, and a fabricated value is worse than none because it silently corrupts a future merge. DO pass `source_drawer_id` on `kg_add`. And never put a machine name in a diary's `agent_name` — it becomes the wing name and hides your entries from `diary_read`.

scripts/smoke-test.sh

@@ -480,18 +480,23 @@ run_expect "pi-devbox-version --quiet is a compact one-liner" \
 run "manifest records the vendored skill snapshot provenance" '
   j=/etc/pi-devbox/build-manifest.json
   r=$(jq -r ".skillset_snapshot_ref // empty" $j)
-  s=$(jq -r ".skillset_snapshot_sha256 // empty" $j)
+  s=$(jq -r ".skillset_snapshot_tree_sha256 // empty" $j)
-  echo "ref=[$r] sha256=[$s]" >&2
+  echo "ref=[$r] tree_sha256=[$s]" >&2
   printf "%s" "$r" | grep -qxE "[0-9a-f]{40}" \
     || { echo "skillset_snapshot_ref is not a 40-hex commit" >&2; exit 1; }
   printf "%s" "$s" | grep -qxE "[0-9a-f]{64}" \
-    || { echo "skillset_snapshot_sha256 is not a 64-hex digest" >&2; exit 1; }
+    || { echo "skillset_snapshot_tree_sha256 is not a 64-hex digest" >&2; exit 1; }
 '
+# Recomputes over the whole DIRECTORY with the same tree_sha256() pipeline
+# Dockerfile.variant used to measure it, not a plain `sha256sum SKILL.md` —
+# a file-only compare here would pass even if the manifest recorded a
+# fingerprint over a directory that has since grown a second file (this is
+# not hypothetical: pi-extensions already ships two files for its skill).
 run "manifest skill fingerprint matches the baked snapshot" '
   j=/etc/pi-devbox/build-manifest.json
-  f=/usr/local/share/pi-devbox/skills/mempalace/SKILL.md
+  d=/usr/local/share/pi-devbox/skills/mempalace
-  m=$(jq -r ".skillset_snapshot_sha256 // empty" $j)
+  m=$(jq -r ".skillset_snapshot_tree_sha256 // empty" $j)
-  a=$(sha256sum "$f" | cut -d" " -f1)
+  a=$( (cd "$d" && find . -type f -print | LC_ALL=C sort | xargs -r sha256sum) | sha256sum | cut -d" " -f1)
   echo "manifest=[$m] actual=[$a]" >&2
   [ -n "$m" ] && [ "$m" = "$a" ]
 '
@@ -615,8 +620,12 @@ exec_test "pi-devbox-version reports skill sources (all baked, no skillset here)
 # version FIRST, before the baked links exist and long before the skillset
 # deploy + reconcile run last, so anything it said about skill sources would be
 # a pre-reconcile state that is about to change.
+# A bare negative (`! grep -q "skills:"`) passes if the tool crashes or
+# prints nothing at all — it cannot tell "correctly omitted the section"
+# apart from "the binary is broken". Anchor it positively: the command must
+# still succeed and still print its normal release-tag line.
 exec_test "pi-devbox-version --no-skills omits the skills section" \
-    '! pi-devbox-version --no-skills | grep -q "skills:"'
+    'out=$(pi-devbox-version --no-skills) && echo "$out" | grep -q "^pi-devbox " && ! echo "$out" | grep -q "skills:"'
 exec_test "entrypoint prints the version banner with --no-skills" \
     'grep -q "pi-devbox-version --no-skills" /usr/local/bin/entrypoint-user.sh'
 # The handover path itself. CI never mounts a skillset, so without this the

scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh

@@ -19,20 +19,53 @@
 # matching ARG bump produces a manifest that CONFIDENTLY LIES — worse than the
 # anonymous snapshot it replaced.
 #
+# HARDENED after peer review (pi@emb-7kj4vr4g, logstream correlation
+# skills-provenance-review, 2026-08-26) proved the original --check could print
+# OK and exit 0 without actually verifying anything: `git show <ref>:<path>`
+# emits NOTHING when the ref/path doesn't resolve, and `sha256sum` still hashes
+# that empty stdin, so "ref not found" silently collided with "the file really
+# is 0 bytes". Depending on which side of the comparison hit the collision this
+# fell through as either a false MISMATCH (blaming provenance for what was
+# really an incomplete clone) or, worse, a false OK. See EXIT STATUS below —
+# "cannot determine" is now its own outcome, distinct from "confirmed wrong",
+# which is the same distinction the phrase canary this script replaced lacked.
+#
 # USAGE
-#   scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh [skillset-root]      refresh + record
+#   scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh [skillset-root] [--force]
-#   scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh --check [root]       verify, write nothing
+#       refresh: rewrite the snapshot and the ARG together.
+#   scripts/vendor-mempalace-skill.sh --check [skillset-root]
+#       verify only, writes nothing. The root path and any flag may appear in
+#       either order — a positional-only parser previously made `<root>
+#       --check` silently run a refresh instead of the verification asked for.
 #
 #   skillset-root defaults to /workspace/skillset, then $HOME/skillset.
 #
+#   --force  (refresh mode only) proceed even when the recorded ref cannot be
+#            proven to be an ancestor of the skillset's current HEAD — i.e.
+#            skip the guard against silently REWINDING provenance, which a
+#            detached HEAD, an older checkout, or a shallow clone lacking the
+#            recorded commit can all trigger. Meant to be used deliberately,
+#            not habitually: each use is a human deciding a rewind is fine.
+#
 # --check answers "is the committed snapshot really skillset@<recorded ref>?"
 # — the question CI cannot answer without a credential for the private repo,
-# and which anyone with the skillset checked out can answer for free. Exit 0
+# and which anyone with the skillset checked out can answer for free.
-# when the snapshot is honest and current, 1 when it is not.
 #
-# EXIT STATUS
+# EXIT STATUS (same three codes in both modes)
-#   0  refreshed (or already up to date; --check: snapshot verified)
+#   0  the operation succeeded, or (--check) the record is verified truthful.
-#   1  refused: dirty upstream file, missing repo, or --check mismatch
+#      This INCLUDES a truthful record that is merely stale — upstream has
+#      moved on since the recorded ref, or the local working tree has since
+#      diverged. A NOTICE is printed to stderr, but the snapshot is not being
+#      accused of lying, so this is not a release-blocking failure. Skipping a
+#      refresh is a legitimate release-day choice (see AGENTS.md); this exit
+#      code is what makes that choice checkable rather than merely asserted.
+#   1  refused: a CONFIRMED problem. Dirty upstream file; a refresh that would
+#      rewind past the recorded ref; or (--check) the vendored bytes provably
+#      do NOT match the file at the recorded ref — a lying record.
+#   2  cannot determine: the recorded ref, or the path at that ref, is not
+#      resolvable in this clone. Commonly a shallow clone missing history, or
+#      a ref that was rewritten or never pushed. Deliberately NOT the same as
+#      1 — "I can't tell" must never be reported as "it's wrong".
 set -euo pipefail
 
 cd "$(dirname "$0")/.."
@@ -42,13 +75,28 @@ VENDORED="rootfs/usr/local/share/pi-devbox/skills/mempalace/SKILL.md"
 ARG_NAME="SKILLSET_SNAPSHOT_REF"
 REL_PATH="skills/mempalace/SKILL.md"
 
+die() { printf '%s: %s\n' "$(basename "$0")" "$1" >&2; exit 1; }
+
+# Parse flags and the optional root path in either order, and reject anything
+# unrecognised rather than silently absorbing it.
 MODE="refresh"
-if [ "${1:-}" = "--check" ]; then
+FORCE=0
-  MODE="check"
+ROOT=""
-  shift
+for arg in "$@"; do
+  case "$arg" in
+    --check) MODE="check" ;;
+    --force) FORCE=1 ;;
+    --*) die "unknown option: $arg" ;;
+    *)
+      [ -z "$ROOT" ] || die "unexpected extra argument: $arg (root already set to $ROOT)"
+      ROOT="$arg"
+      ;;
+  esac
+done
+if [ "$MODE" = "check" ] && [ "$FORCE" = 1 ]; then
+  die "--force has no effect with --check (nothing is written); remove it"
 fi
 
-ROOT="${1:-}"
 if [ -z "$ROOT" ]; then
   for candidate in /workspace/skillset "$HOME/skillset"; do
     if [ -d "$candidate/.git" ]; then
@@ -58,35 +106,33 @@ if [ -z "$ROOT" ]; then
   done
 fi
 
-die() { printf '%s: %s\n' "$(basename "$0")" "$1" >&2; exit 1; }
-
 [ -n "$ROOT" ] || die "no skillset clone found (pass one: $(basename "$0") /path/to/skillset)"
 [ -d "$ROOT/.git" ] || die "not a git clone: $ROOT"
 [ -f "$ROOT/$REL_PATH" ] || die "no $REL_PATH in $ROOT"
 [ -f "$VENDORED" ] || die "vendored snapshot missing: $VENDORED"
+[ -s "$VENDORED" ] || die "vendored snapshot is empty: $VENDORED"
 
 head_sha=$(git -C "$ROOT" rev-parse HEAD 2>/dev/null) || die "cannot read HEAD of $ROOT"
 recorded=$(grep -oE "^ARG ${ARG_NAME}=[0-9a-f]{40}$" "$DOCKERFILE" | cut -d= -f2 || true)
 [ -n "$recorded" ] || die "no 'ARG ${ARG_NAME}=<40-hex>' line in $DOCKERFILE"
 
 sha_of() { sha256sum "$1" | cut -d' ' -f1; }
-sha_empty=$(printf '' | sha256sum | cut -d' ' -f1)
 vendored_sha=$(sha_of "$VENDORED")
 upstream_sha=$(sha_of "$ROOT/$REL_PATH")
 
-# The recorded ref must PROVABLY describe the recorded bytes. Reviewed by
+# Does $REL_PATH exist at HEAD at all? Proven with `cat-file -e` BEFORE
-# pi@emb-7kj4vr4g (logstream correlation skillset-vendor-drift, 2026-08-26):
+# hashing anything. Piping a failed `git show` straight into sha256sum, as
-# "make sure the resync script writes the ref it ACTUALLY copied from, or the
+# this script used to, hashes an EMPTY stream and produces sha256(""): a real,
-# provenance field inherits the same class of bug the canary just had." So this
+# collidable value — not a representation of absence. That collapsed "doesn't
-# does not copy the working tree and then hope a `git diff` was enough — a
+# exist" and "exists and happens to be empty" into the same signal, which is
-# clean-looking `git diff` says nothing about an UNTRACKED file, and a detached
+# exactly the defect class the peer review found in --check's at_ref, below.
-# or behind checkout can be clean while HEAD names something else. Instead the
+blob_sha=""
-# snapshot is CONSTRUCTED from the ref being recorded (below), and the working
+if git -C "$ROOT" cat-file -e "HEAD:$REL_PATH" 2>/dev/null; then
-# tree is compared only so a local edit produces a refusal rather than a silent
+  blob_sha=$(git -C "$ROOT" show "HEAD:$REL_PATH" | sha256sum | cut -d' ' -f1)
-# surprise. Order matters here: everything this block reads is defined above it.
+fi
-blob_sha=$(git -C "$ROOT" show "HEAD:$REL_PATH" 2>/dev/null | sha256sum | cut -d' ' -f1 || true)
+
 upstream_dirty=""
-if [ -z "$blob_sha" ] || [ "$blob_sha" = "$sha_empty" ]; then
+if [ -z "$blob_sha" ]; then
   upstream_dirty="not present at HEAD (untracked, or absent at this commit)"
 elif [ "$blob_sha" != "$upstream_sha" ]; then
   if ! git -C "$ROOT" diff --quiet -- "$REL_PATH" 2>/dev/null; then
@@ -99,17 +145,41 @@ elif [ "$blob_sha" != "$upstream_sha" ]; then
 fi
 
 if [ "$MODE" = "check" ]; then
-  # Compare the committed snapshot against the file AT THE RECORDED REF, not
+  # Resolve the recorded ref the same careful way: existence is proven with
-  # against the working tree: the question is whether the record is truthful,
+  # `cat-file -e` before anything is hashed, and "the ref itself is missing"
-  # which is independent of how current it is. Both are reported.
+  # is reported distinctly from "the ref resolves but the path isn't there
-  at_ref=$(git -C "$ROOT" show "${recorded}:${REL_PATH}" 2>/dev/null | sha256sum | cut -d' ' -f1 || true)
+  # at it" — both used to be silently swallowed into a plausible sha256("").
+  ref_exists=0
+  path_at_ref_exists=0
+  at_ref=""
+  if git -C "$ROOT" cat-file -e "${recorded}^{commit}" 2>/dev/null; then
+    ref_exists=1
+    if git -C "$ROOT" cat-file -e "${recorded}:${REL_PATH}" 2>/dev/null; then
+      path_at_ref_exists=1
+      at_ref=$(git -C "$ROOT" show "${recorded}:${REL_PATH}" | sha256sum | cut -d' ' -f1)
+    fi
+  fi
+
   printf 'recorded ref:      %s\n' "$recorded"
   printf 'vendored sha256:   %s\n' "$vendored_sha"
-  printf 'sha256 at ref:     %s\n' "${at_ref:-<ref not present in this clone>}"
+  if [ "$path_at_ref_exists" = 1 ]; then
-  printf 'skillset HEAD:     %s (%s)\n' "$head_sha" "$(sha_of "$ROOT/$REL_PATH")"
+    printf 'sha256 at ref:     %s\n' "$at_ref"
+  elif [ "$ref_exists" = 1 ]; then
+    printf 'sha256 at ref:     <%s not present at %s>\n' "$REL_PATH" "${recorded:0:7}"
+  else
+    printf 'sha256 at ref:     <%s not present in this clone>\n' "${recorded:0:7}"
+  fi
+  printf 'skillset HEAD:     %s (%s)\n' "$head_sha" "$upstream_sha"
+  if [ -n "$upstream_dirty" ]; then
+    printf 'live working tree: %s\n' "$upstream_dirty"
+  fi
+
   rc=0
-  if [ -z "$at_ref" ]; then
+  if [ "$ref_exists" != 1 ]; then
-    printf 'UNKNOWN: %s is not in this clone — fetch, or check against a complete one\n' "$recorded" >&2
+    printf 'CANNOT-DETERMINE: %s is not present in %s — fetch, or check against a complete clone\n' "$recorded" "$ROOT" >&2
+    rc=2
+  elif [ "$path_at_ref_exists" != 1 ]; then
+    printf 'MISMATCH: %s does not exist at %s in this clone — the recorded ref cannot be describing these bytes\n' "$REL_PATH" "$recorded" >&2
     rc=1
   elif [ "$at_ref" != "$vendored_sha" ]; then
     printf 'MISMATCH: the vendored snapshot is NOT the file at the recorded ref\n' >&2
@@ -117,19 +187,27 @@ if [ "$MODE" = "check" ]; then
   else
     printf 'OK: the vendored snapshot is exactly skillset@%s:%s\n' "${recorded:0:7}" "$REL_PATH"
   fi
-  if [ "$vendored_sha" != "$upstream_sha" ]; then
+
+  # Staleness is orthogonal to truthfulness: a record can correctly describe
+  # an old commit even after upstream has moved on, and a dirty local working
+  # tree in $ROOT doesn't rewrite git history either — it says nothing about
+  # whether the RECORDED, committed ref describes the RECORDED, committed
+  # bytes. Only worth reporting once we already know rc=0 (truthful) — a
+  # MISMATCH or CANNOT-DETERMINE is the dominant fact and a staleness note
+  # would only muddy it.
+  if [ "$rc" = 0 ] && [ "$vendored_sha" != "$upstream_sha" ]; then
     # Name the ACTUAL cause. "working tree differs" is wrong when the tree is
-    # clean and the ref simply moved on — a message that names the wrong cause is
+    # clean and the ref simply moved on — a message that names the wrong cause
-    # the same defect class as a canary pinned to a deleted phrase.
+    # is the same defect class as a canary pinned to a deleted phrase.
     if [ "$recorded" != "$head_sha" ] && [ "$blob_sha" = "$upstream_sha" ]; then
-      printf 'STALE: %s has moved to %s; the snapshot describes the older %s\n' \
+      printf 'NOTICE: %s has moved to %s; the snapshot describes the older %s (stale, not untruthful)\n' \
         "$ROOT" "${head_sha:0:7}" "${recorded:0:7}" >&2
     else
-      printf 'STALE: the working tree of %s differs from the snapshot (HEAD %s)\n' \
+      printf 'NOTICE: the working tree of %s differs from the snapshot (HEAD %s)\n' \
-      "$ROOT" "${head_sha:0:7}" >&2
+        "$ROOT" "${head_sha:0:7}" >&2
     fi
-    rc=1
   fi
+
   exit "$rc"
 fi
 
@@ -140,21 +218,45 @@ if [ "$vendored_sha" = "$upstream_sha" ] && [ "$recorded" = "$head_sha" ]; then
   exit 0
 fi
 
-# Written FROM THE REF, not copied from the working tree, so the pair cannot be
+# Refuse to silently REWIND provenance. `git checkout <tag>`, a detached HEAD,
-# a lie by construction. Via a temp file so a failed write cannot leave a
+# or an older checkout can all leave $ROOT's HEAD behind the already-recorded
+# ref; without this guard a refresh there would happily rewrite both the ARG
+# and the bytes backwards and report it as an ordinary update.
+if [ "$recorded" != "$head_sha" ]; then
+  if git -C "$ROOT" cat-file -e "${recorded}^{commit}" 2>/dev/null; then
+    if ! git -C "$ROOT" merge-base --is-ancestor "$recorded" "$head_sha" 2>/dev/null; then
+      if [ "$FORCE" != 1 ]; then
+        die "refusing: $ROOT's HEAD ($head_sha) is not a descendant of the recorded ref ($recorded) — this looks like a rewind. Pass --force if this is intentional."
+      fi
+      printf 'WARNING: --force set; %s is not an ancestor of HEAD %s — proceeding anyway\n' "${recorded:0:7}" "${head_sha:0:7}" >&2
+    fi
+  else
+    if [ "$FORCE" != 1 ]; then
+      printf 'CANNOT-DETERMINE: %s is not present in %s (shallow clone?) — fetch full history to verify this refresh moves forward, or pass --force to proceed without that guarantee\n' "$recorded" "$ROOT" >&2
+      exit 2
+    fi
+    printf 'WARNING: --force set; %s could not be resolved in %s — proceeding without verifying forward motion\n' "${recorded:0:7}" "$ROOT" >&2
+  fi
+fi
+
+# Written FROM THE REF, not copied from the working tree, so the pair cannot
+# be a lie by construction. Via a temp file so a failed write cannot leave a
 # half-vendored snapshot behind.
 snap_tmp=$(mktemp)
 if ! git -C "$ROOT" show "HEAD:$REL_PATH" > "$snap_tmp" 2>/dev/null; then
   rm -f -- "$snap_tmp"
   die "cannot read HEAD:$REL_PATH from $ROOT"
 fi
+chmod 0644 -- "$snap_tmp"
 mv -- "$snap_tmp" "$VENDORED"
 [ "$(sha_of "$VENDORED")" = "$blob_sha" ] \
   || die "internal: written snapshot does not match HEAD:$REL_PATH"
-# In-place, and only the exact pinned line: a broad sed on this Dockerfile could
+
-# rewrite one of the other *_REF ARGs.
+# In-place, and only the exact pinned line: a broad sed on this Dockerfile
+# could rewrite one of the other *_REF ARGs.
 tmp=$(mktemp)
-sed "s|^ARG ${ARG_NAME}=.*$|ARG ${ARG_NAME}=${head_sha}|" "$DOCKERFILE" > "$tmp"
+sed "s|^ARG ${ARG_NAME}=.*\$|ARG ${ARG_NAME}=${head_sha}|" "$DOCKERFILE" > "$tmp"
+chmod 0644 -- "$tmp"
 mv -- "$tmp" "$DOCKERFILE"
 
 new_recorded=$(grep -oE "^ARG ${ARG_NAME}=[0-9a-f]{40}$" "$DOCKERFILE" | cut -d= -f2 || true)